Friday, March 01, 2013

The Marikana Massacre and Lessons for the Left

The new Irish Marxist Review (IMR5) will be available online soon at www.irishmarxistreview.net . As a taster here is one of the articles.




The Marikana Massacre and Lessons for the Left

Mary Smith

TV coverage of the Marikana massacre had a sickening sense of déjà vu about it; uniformed men, rifles aimed, the crack of gunfire, black bodies in the dust - Sharpeville, Soweto, iconic images of South Africa under Apartheid. But this was August 16th 2012, not the last century; the killers took their orders not from the old racist Apartheid regime of Botha or de Klerk, but from the state headed by the ‘liberators’ - the African National Congress (ANC).

Another image of South Africa: the long patient queues, waiting since dawn to vote for the first time; hope and pride and joy in the faces. That was 1994 - the year the struggle had smashed through Apartheid and ushered in a government led by the ANC, pledged to ‘peace, jobs, freedom’.

So how could it have come to this, to state-sponsored murder, eighteen years later?
One of the leading unions in the Confederation of South African Trades Unions (COSATU) commented that “..[Marikana] must go down in our history as the first post-apartheid South African State massacre of the organised working class, in defence of the local and international mining bosses and their profits.”[1] This article attempts to explain not only why such a thing could happen but why it was almost inevitable that it should. But first we look at the massacre itself – the events surrounding it and the wider relevance of the strike.

A local reporter describing the events of August 16th 2012 writes:

 “Of the 34 miners killed at Marikana, no more than a dozen of the dead were captured in news footage shot at the scene. The majority of those who died, according to surviving strikers and researchers, were killed beyond the view of cameras at a nondescript collection of boulders some 300 metres behind Wonderkop.
On one of these rocks, encompassed closely on all sides by solid granite boulders, is the letter ‘N’, the 14th letter of the alphabet. Here, N represents the 14th body of a striking miner to be found by a police forensics team in this isolated place. These letters are used by forensics to detail were the corpses lay.
There is a thick spread of blood deep into the dry soil, showing that N was shot and killed on the spot. There is no trail of blood leading to where N died – the blood saturates one spot only, indicating no further movement. (It would have been outside of the scope of the human body to crawl here bleeding so profusely.)
Approaching N from all possible angles, observing the local geography, it is clear that to shoot N, the shooter would have to be close. Very close, in fact, almost within touching distance. (After having spent days here at the bloody massacre site, it does not take too much imagination for me to believe that N might have begged for his life on that winter afternoon.)
And on the deadly Thursday afternoon, N’s murderer could only have been a policeman. I say murderer because there is not a single report on an injured policeman from the day. I say murderer because there seems to have been no attempt to uphold our citizens’ right to life and fair recourse to justice. It is hard to imagine that N would have resisted being taken into custody when thus cornered. There is no chance of escape out of a ring of police”.[2]

This interpretation of the killings is supported by an investigating team comprising Peter Alexander, chair in Social Change and Professor of Sociology at the University of Johannesburg, and researchers Thapelo Lekgowa and Botsang Mmope, outlined below:

Follow the numbered events on the accompanying map to understand how shocking was this premeditated slaughter.


1: On the day of the killing about 3,000 striking miners were gathered on and just below the “mountain” (actually a small hill). Joseph Mathunjwa, president of the union, the Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union (AMCU), came and pleaded with them to leave to avoid a police attack. The miners refused.
2: Within 15 minutes of Mathunjwa leaving, the police and army laid razor wire, separating the strikers from the Enkanini informal settlement, where many of them live. Casspirs (armoured cars), horses and water cannon moved up to encircle the workers.
3: Some workers walked down to the razor wire to see if they could still get out through a gap. Witnesses say police near the “small koppie” (hillock) opened fire on them, probably with rubber bullets.
Some workers fled through a five metre gap in the razor wire. They were met with a barrage of live fire from the police and many died. Images of this shooting were broadcast around the world.
4: Terrified strikers scattered in all directions, with a large number heading for cover by a koppie about 300 metres in the opposite direction from the wire. This “killing koppie” is where the largest number of strikers died.
No cameras recorded this slaughter. But evidence remained on Monday, four days after the massacre. There are remnants of pools of blood. Police markers show where corpses were removed. We found markers labeled with letters up to ‘J’.
5-8: Other strikers were killed as they fled across the fields. Some examples are marked on the map. Shots were fired from helicopters and some workers, heading for hillock, were crushed by Casspirs.
By Monday the whole area had been swept clean of rubber bullets, bullet casings and tear-gas canisters. We also saw patches of burned grass, which local workers claim are the remains of police fires used to obscure evidence of deaths.[3]

Following the massacre, the community of Marikana lived under a virtual state of emergency, with police patrols, raids and reports of unlawful arrests and harassment. Most of the miners who were killed and badly injured were sole breadwinners, and the loss of their earnings has left many of their dependents in a desperate situation.
The State has set up a Commission of Inquiry under retired judge Ian Farlam, that already, less than two months into its expected six month duration, is cruelly flawed. A new publication based on first hand accounts of the killings and their aftermath by the miners themselves makes the following observation:

[The commission] aims to provide ‘truth and justice’ on the basis of evidence presented to the commissioners, but it has not observed working conditions underground and operates in a courtroom environment alienating for ordinary people. In fact, key leaders of the workers’ committee have been arrested, intimidated and tortured during the time in which the commission has taken place, and we therefore question the extent to which the commission is able to provide a space that is not biased against the workers’ perspective. [4]

Initially, half of the Lonmin Strike Committee, due to testify before the Commission, were charged with the murder of their own colleagues, under an old Apartheid era law of “common purpose”. These charges were subsequently ‘provisionally dropped’, after public protest and threatened unrest but not one police officer or official has been charged in relation to the massacre. Meanwhile relatives of those killed make long, difficult journeys to attend the Commission. UK-based barrister James Nicholl traveled to South Africa to participate as one of the legal team supporting the miners and their families. As well as formal duties attached to this role, he sends to his friends and colleagues back home, brief "reflections and impressions", as he describes them, of the day-to-day proceedings in the court. He sent the following before Xmas:

Finally, after 3 weeks and a 1000 kms, grieving widows, mothers sisters and brothers have arrived. Their neglect shameful, and continues...Video footage shown without warning, machine guns, dead bodies…Weeping, uncontrollable fills the auditorium, most have not seen before, most have no television, most have no electricity. There are no shoulders to cry on, no-one to hug, only one person per family, allowed…too expensive. We warned the Commission - many times… ignored. They rejected trauma and bereavement councilors paid for (by many of you) from the Marikana Support Campaign.

The Strike.

There is heavy, and growing, government interference in the media in South Africa [5]. So it is no surprise that from the outset, Marikana was presented as a sectional strike by an irresponsible group of unorganised, unskilled ‘renegades’ with criminal intent. The reality is very different. The backbone of the strike were the rock drill operators (RDOs) in the platinum mines; South Africa holds 88 percent of the world’s platinum reserves and accounts for over three quarters of global platinum production. Platinum plays a crucial role in South Africa’s economy, particularly since the decline in gold extraction, but has been hit by the drop in demand with the onset of global recession.  Lonmin[6], the British owned company at Marikana, were determined to avoid a repeat of events at the neighbouring Impala platinum mine where, in January, a militant strike lasting six weeks, cost Impala €200 million and stopped almost half of national platinum output. The Impala strike also saw the growth of the new union AMCU, and of its power to shut down production. This terrified the mining bosses as well as the corrupt leadership of the now discredited National Union of Mineworkers (NUM), who openly collaborated with the industry and the State against the striking miners.
The ANC government had identified platinum as central to its resource-based development strategy; planning for a new “platinum valley” to concentrate platinum-based manufacturing industries. But these plans were severely hit by the global crisis and a dramatic fall in the price of platinum. According to Gavin Capps, a specialist at the University of Cape Town, the earlier scramble to expand production has now led to a situation of global over-supply[7].
The demand by the Marikana strikers was for a tripling of their wages to R12,500 a month, which on the face of it sounds surprising, until you realize that these men work ten to twelve hour shifts underground, in the dirtiest, most dangerous conditions (the RDOs are among the lowest paid), in 35 degree heat and all for less than the equivalent of €90 per week. (Over the last century, the mining industry in South Africa has had a notorious safety record with well in excess of 50,000 deaths).
Claire Ceruti, South African socialist and solidarity activist explains that the workers organized their strike without an established union presence - the AMCU stepping in only in an advisory role only as the strike progressed. The action was organized  by an elected strike committee who were incredibly democratic – so much so that solidarity action was initially difficult to initiate as everything had to be discussed first with the committee, and then by the strikers themselves.[8] The courage, tenacity, and organizational strength the rock-drillers have shown, and continue to show, in the face of State repression, has inspired workers not only in mining but right across the industrial spectrum, and previously unorganized, ‘unskilled’ workers like security guards and grape pickers have gone on the offensive for their own minimum wage demands.
The Unions under Apartheid.
Marx explained over a century and a half ago that capitalism creates ‘its own gravedigger’ – the working class. The Apartheid state shaped, and was shaped by, this process in a very particular way. Ever since gold and diamonds were discovered in South Africa in the 1880s, a constant supply of cheap, migrant labour was the condition on which the mining industry depended for its profitability. Apartheid was not just a system of cruel, racist laws that made black people second class citizens in their own country, it was, most importantly, a way of managing the huge battalions of black migrant labour necessary to this process. Racism, the denial of rights to black Africans and paying poverty wages, had been practiced by the colonial powers in South Africa, both British and Boers – but it wasn’t until 1948 that the system of Apartheid was formalised and codified. The hated Pass Laws, the creation of the artificial ‘homelands’ or Bantustans, the enormous (white run) bureaucracy that policed the movement of black people – all enforced with pitiless repression – this was the Apartheid state . From 1948 to 1993 over 2000 people who fought against it were hanged, thousands were imprisoned and millions were arrested and/or displaced to distant ‘homelands’ to languish there in abject poverty as surplus or ‘unproductive’ labour. The bitterness of this legacy helped fuel the militancy of one of the most impressive contingents of the world’s workers – the black South African working class.
The black trade unions first made their presence felt during World War Two. This was when the then radical National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) was formed, leading its members in a demand for ten shillings (this represented a 500 percent increase!). The strike, which mobilized thousands of workers eventually won, but the state machine also went on the offensive against the workers’ movement. Alex Callinicos, writing of the period says that, “The destruction of black political and trade union organization was both the condition of apartheid’s success and its objective”[9]. Over the following decades, despite the repression, struggles emerged that were political as well as economic – bus boycotts, the women’s movement, township revolts, student rebellions, community struggles - all fed into the industrial struggle which in turn fuelled the political one. But the core was the black working class.
Charlie Kimber in his review of literature dealing with the struggle against Apartheid writes:
The modern union movement was born after a wave of strikes in 1973 centred on the area around Durban. Despite immense repression it grew, slowly, during the 1970s so that by the end of the decade it clearly posed a real potential threat to apartheid's rulers”.[10] The trades union movement had ‘given powerless people a chance to wield power for the first time in their lives’ [11].
Kimber makes the crucial point that  “The state could torture and murder activists, it could infiltrate and repress community organisations, it could murder the guerillas sent to challenge its military might. But it could not destroy the unions or blunt their economic power”. [12]

Politics and the workers’ movement.
The so called Tripartite Alliance of the ANC, the South African Communist Party (SACP) and COSATU, runs the SA State. This political marriage was (and remains) based on a shared notion that an all-class alliance of progressive forces in South Africa was necessary to achieve ‘national liberation’ from the Apartheid state and establish ‘normal’ bourgeois or capitalist democracy, where black and white would be treated as equals. Eighteen years on from the ending of Apartheid, this is still the underpinning ideology – all classes must work together to establish the type of state than can deliver on its promise of equality and prosperity for all.
Meantime South Africa remains one of the most unequal societies on the planet; unemployment is double what it was when the ANC were elected, one in four South African children are malnourished, one in ten people still use stinking bucket toilets. The black middle class has grown and a tiny black elite has made itself fabulously wealthy. Anti-apartheid activist archbishop Desmond Tutu famously said that the ANC government had “stopped the gravy train only long enough to get on”. But the situation that obtains is not just down to the personal failings of greedy individuals. The explanation for why it has come to this is a political one.
Here it is instructive to look at the politics of the SCAP - it was they who provided the ideological cement that held the nationalist ANC and the workers’ movement together. Their political strategy is based on a ‘stages theory’ approach to achieving social change – where workers demands are put on the back burner until the bourgeois democratic revolution has been won. Its origins are part of the legacy of Stalinism – a legacy that required that the Communist Parties which developed internationally under the inspiration of the Bolshevik Revolution of 1917, would serve as ‘outposts’ of Russia’s foreign policy, rather than fomenting revolution at home. This started in the 1920s in China, could be seen at work in Europe in the thirties in the struggle against fascism, and in the anti colonial struggles in India, Africa and beyond.
The argument, which always tends to appear in anti-colonialist struggles, goes like this: first we need maximum unity of all classes to get rid of the colonial power and achieve national liberation. Thus talk of socialism, or workers’ power, must be put on hold, lest the non-worker elements - the middle classes, and ‘progressive’ or ‘national’ capitalists, take fright. Once we have gotten rid of apartheid (or the colonial power), we can then move on to build the society we want. The same logic was at work in the post 1916 liberation struggle here in Ireland, illustrated in Ken Loach’s film ‘The Wind the Shakes the Barley’) when workers’ gains during the incredible wave of militancy during the ‘War of Independence’, were curtailed and then rolled back by the nationalist leadership, with the instruction that ‘labour must wait’. For us in Ireland there is an important parallel between the trajectory of the ANC and that of Fianna Fáil which also has implications for Sinn Féin now. Fianna Fáil in the 1920s said and did much more radical things that Sinn Féin do today – and then went on to become Ireland’s leading capitalist party with consequences we all know about.
Writing about the relationship between the ANC and SACP, Peter Dwyer and Leo Zelig put it this way:
 The history of building multi-class popular alliances goes back to the African nationalist leadership of the ANC under Nelson Mandela, Walter Sisulu and Oliver Tambo in the 1950s. Recognizing that industrialization and urbanization were changing the social composition of African society, they sought to build alliances with trades unions and working class township communities. This strategy dovetailed with that of the Communist Party, which, under orders from Moscow, pursued a “people’s front” that brought together differing social groups to strengthen national liberation.[13].
The sad history of ‘stagism’ in national liberation movements is that it never moves beyond the first stage – the establishment of ‘normal’ capitalist democracy – neither in Africa nor Ireland nor anywhere else. The second stage – the struggle for socialism, when the working class can have their day well… that comes later. When? When the nation state is properly established…. when the economy has become stable….when the industrial base is developed…when we’ve attracted enough investment for jobs…some ‘tomorrow’. Despite the apparent ‘common sense’ appeal of the stagist approach, history shows that the postponed ‘tomorrow’ for workers never comes, or when it does – it’s Marikana. This is because regardless of whether the administration of a capitalist state is black or white, (or whether they wear the ‘green jersey’ or once led the IRA), when capitalism itself is the basis of economic relations in the society then it’s the interests of capital that will dominate.
In the years of the freedom struggle, the politics of the SACP bridged the gap between the aspiration to ‘socialism’ of the rising workers movement and  the nationalist politics of the ANC Like all national liberation movements, the ANC’s political aspirations were primarily for a national (capitalist) state, free from colonialdomination. Apartheid was theorized by the SACP as a form of ‘internal colonialism’; liberation then was the ending of Apartheid, which, once gotten rid of, would allow for ‘business as usual’, and could include ‘normal’ left versus ‘right’ politics. The SCAP strategy chimed with COSATU on the basis that once the national democratic state was established, then the task of getting a workers, or socialist democracy in a free South Africa would /should be taken up. NUM leader Cyril Ramaphosa opened the founding conference of COSATU in 1985 with the following statement:
 If workers are to lead the struggle for liberation we have to win the confidence of other sections of society. But if we are to get into alliances with other progressive organisations, it must be on terms that are favourable to us as workers. When we do plunge into political activity we must make sure that the unions under COSATU have a strong shop floor base not only to take on the employers but the state as well. In the next few days we will be putting our heads together not only to make sure we reach Pretoria but to make a better life for us workers in this country. What we have to make clear is that a giant has risen and will confront all that stand in its way [14]
By its second conference, COSATU had adopted the ANC’s Freedom Charter – a document containing no mention of socialism, and certainly no primacy of place for workers. The same Cyril Ramaphosa incidentally is today a multi millionaire and among his directorships is included the platinum mining corporation at Lonmin!
Could it have been different?
Nelson Mandela, jailed for 27 years, in his first speech after his release said: “There must be an end to white monopoly on political power and a fundamental restructuring of our political and economic systems to ensure that the inequalities of apartheid are addressed and our society thoroughly democratised.” Yet the very first act of the ANC-led interim government was to accept an $850 million loan from the International Monetary Fund. Patrick Bond said of it: “The loan’s secret conditions ….included the usual items from the classical structural adjustment menu: lower import tariffs, cuts in state spending, and large cuts in public sector wages.”
The newly elected government quickly abandoned such policies as nationalization, particularly of the mines, that could have given them control over wealth accumulated in private hands. More and more, neoliberalism came to dominate economic policy and more and more the new government sought to squash any systematic opposition to it. One of the best organised and most militant working classes in the world was held back as the Communist Party’s leadership justified the ANC regime’s shifts. Trade union militants became caught up in a process of stopping strikes rather than encouraging them.
What was required to counter this was politics that sought to harness the power of workers in the interests of workers themselves. The theoretical basis for such politics was to be found in  the theory of permanent revolution developed by Leon Trotsky, first in response to the 1905 Revolution in Russia and then in direct opposition to the stages theory of Stalinism in the 1920s. This argued that the working class should take the lead in the democratic or anti-colonial struggle so that the national revolution could ‘grow over’ into the socialist revolution. In South Africa it was the threat posed by the militancy of black workers in their factories, mines and communities that forced the hand of the ruling class into getting rid of apartheid. This power could have been channeled not in the direction of a weak (stagist) compromise, but in a much more thorough-going challenge to the capitalist bosses. Tragically, the political forces that could have given this lead were too small and too weak to challenge the hegemony of the SACP.
A song from the heroic battles of miners in the USA in the 1900s poses the question ‘Which side are you on’? Settling for a stagist solution ultimately places those who have advocated social change on the side of the capitalists, despite themselves. The logic of securing the ‘first stage’ – the bourgeois democracy – means that stability of the capitalist state is paramount. This is what makes events like Marikana almost inevitable, especially when the system is facing crisis. Profits in South African platinum mining have seen a decline since the onset of global recession. The last thing the platinum bosses need is a newly invigorated movement of mineworkers. It is also the last thing the corrupt leadership of the NUM want to see. And if the platinum industry isn’t kept happy, it can threaten the state with disinvestment, with repatriating even more of its profits than it does already, or laying off workers (in a country where unemployment currently stands at around 40%). In such circumstances, the state does what it has to do – and if that means Marikana, then that what it means.
Keeping capital happy also means particularly vile tendencies get free reign; thus we see the former firebrand - miners’ leader Cyril Ramaphosa - grabbing multiple top directorships including a directorship of Lonmin. An email he sent to one of his fellow Lonmin directors on the eve of the massacre at Marikana was presented as evidence at the Farlam Commission of Inquiry into the killings of the striking miners. It read: "They are plainly dastardly criminals and must be characterised as such...There needs to be concomitant action to address this situation".[15]
The response of the SACP to the massacre speaks for itself. At its congress in September, just after the killings, general secretary Balde Nzimande pledged his party’s support for ‘the government’s crackdown’, adding that ‘the ringleaders must be dealt with and separated from the mass of misled strikers’[16]. The NUM’s leaders are also part of the SACP leadership and the party is closely identified with the Zuma faction in the ANC[17].
Victory for the miners
The Marikana miners have paid dearly for their victory. They won a 22% increase in pay – far short of the original demand but unprecedented in industrial claims in the past forty years. But it is in the wider implications of the outcome that their true victory lies as the Alexander-led research team remarked “…worker organizations in the mines will never be the same again. Thousands of workers have rejected their old union [the collaborationist NUM] and many of these have linked strike mobilization to politics in a new way.” [18] In addition, since the strike, hundreds and thousands of South African workers have been inspired to take militant action, particularly in securing minimum wage deals across a range of industries reliant on ‘unskilled’ workers. Crucially Marikana has called into question the role of the government and the deference with which the ANC has been treated hitherto. The Marikana miners took on the bosses, armed police, the government, corrupt union officials and beat them. Despite thirty four killings, hundreds of arrests, torture and intimidation they held their own organization, and their strike, together. As the researchers said of it “This was one of the most remarkable acts of courage in labour history, anywhere, and at any time.” [19]
In a ‘Special Report’ on the ANC in the Guardian David Smith states “Bishop Jo Seoka, president of the South African Council of Churches, recently warned that a revolution could go from mines and grape farms to townships and suburbs. Moeletsi Mbeki, a political economist and brother of the former president Thabo Mbeki, predicted South Africa’s ‘Tunisia Day’ will come in 2020”[20].He might need to revise the timescale! Since 2005, South Africa has probably had more strike days per capita than any other country.[21] In addition, South Africa’s level of ongoing urban unrest is greater than anywhere else in the world, and there were more community protests in the first six months of 2012 than in any previous year.[22] Meanwhile, the Marikana widows and families endure with courage and dignity the State-sponsored Farlam Commission of Inquiry; they are determined to get ‘justice’ for their loved ones and their communities. The Marikana Support Campaign has issued an appeal for solidarity internationally. The appeal is reproduced below.
Marikana and Ireland
Marikana has particular relevance for Ireland. Nelson Mandela was a heroic leader; he and his comrades pursued the fight against apartheid with courage and tenacity under the banner of national liberation. He was co-founder of the ANC’s ‘armed wing’– Umkhonto we Sizwe (or MK), translated "Spear of the Nation". They were branded as terrorists and reviled in the media. Eventually the more far sighted members of the South African capitalist class saw that apartheid could no longer deliver in the same old way and that the struggle to end it was helping to create what it feared most – a militant working class. And so they did a deal with Mandela and the ANC; history shows that nationalists, however radical, always do a deal with capitalism. The deal was to get rid of the apartheid state but to leave the capitalist order intact – the first stage in the ‘stages theory’ thus achieved. The next stage has become the consolidation of the ‘free’ South African  state, in which ‘labour must wait’. And when labour gets impatient with poverty wages and rotten living conditions, Marikana shows what the ANC are now willing to do.
Many Irish workers today look to as a radical alternative to the sell-outs of the Labour Party – indeed SF’s provenance would have many similarities with that of the ANC. But what is most important is the politics they share – the politics of nationalism - that ultimately put the interests of capital, before the interests of workers, of the platinum bosses before the miners. Of course Sinn Féin would reject the notion that they would sell-out working people in this way. But we need only look to what they do in office in the North, implementing Tory cuts, to see where they are likely to go in the South. Moreover, it is significant that they refuse to rule out coalition with Fianna Fáil. As the old joke goes ‘What’s the difference between Fianna Fáil and Sinn Féin? Answer: About seventy years!”
The struggle for workers’ power and real democracy must be informed by different politics – revolutionary socialist politics – in order to have a chance of success. The project is the same, from Durban to Dublin, from Cape Town to Cork. The spirit of the Marikana miners will live in all these struggles. It is our duty as socialists to see that these struggles are imbued with the politics that can lead them to victory.
Note: it is with some pride that we record the fact that James Nicholl, one of the lawyers representing the miners and their families, is a long standing member of the SWP in Britain, that Peter Alexander, co-author of the report, now published as Marikana: A View from the Mountain and a Case to Answer, Bookmarks, 2013, was a long standing member until his move to South Africa and that they, together with Claire Ceruti and Rehad Desai, activists in the solidarity campaign, are all supporters of the International Socialist Tendency.

Marikana Support Campaign 
An Urgent Call for International Solidarity
On the 16th August, South African Police fired live ammunition at striking miners at Lonmin’s Marikana mine, killing 34 and injuring 78. Many were killed were shot at close rangewhile trying to surrender. The Marikana miners were demanding a tripling of their salary to R12,500 (£950 or €1100) per month.  
In the following days, 270 of the Marikana strikers were arrested and charged with the murder of their colleagues under the Common Purpose doctrine, a law last used under Apartheid. They were released on bail after public pressure forced the National Prosecuting Authority to provisionally drop the charges. Since the massacre the community of Marikana has lived under a virtual State of Emergency, with police patrols, raids and reports of unlawful arrests and harassment. Over half of the Lonmin Strike Committee due to testify before the Commission of Inquiry have been over the past days charged with murder. 
To date not one police officer or official has been charged for the massacre at Marikana. Yet some of the miners still face the prospect of long prison sentences as the State intends to blame the miners themselves for the violence. Most of the miners who were killed and badly injured in Marikana were sole breadwinners and the loss of their earnings has left many of their dependents in a desperate situation.
The Marikana Lonmin miners secured a 22 percent pay rise. It was short of the R12,500demand but the deal was hailed as a victory. What the miners have actually done is fight a brave fight for a living wage. They have drawn public attention to the gap between the wages of mine workers and platinum and gold sector bosses, many of whom earn 1000 times more than the average miner. The massacre and the victory have inspired strikes in other mines across the country. The Marikana Support Campaign has been endorsed by the various strike committees and this has raised the demand for campaign material.  
What the Campaign has achieved so far
The campaign and legal representatives have kept vigilant watch on the State sponsored Farlam Commission of Inquiry, pushing for transparency and forcing a postponement to ensure the presence of families so that the restorative objective of the commission can be met more effectively.In addition the campaign has organised legal representation for twenty six of the families, paid for a private forensic pathologist, kept close watch on biased media reporting and offered alternative analysis, mobilised for practical support and resources for the families of the strikers, organised placard protests of the loco inspection of the killing site as well as nationwide pickets and demonstrations demanding an end to police harassment and intimidation of the Marikana community, brought large numbers of people to Marikana to bolster locally organised protests and to attend strike and community meetings, produced campaign materials, badges, leaflets and T-shirts etc; organised striker and community representative speaking tours in cities and townships across the country. 
All of this costs money. In the coming months we need to increase the pressure on the Farlam Commission of Inquiry through a coordinated national and international campaign that presses for a just outcome for the Marikana families of the deceased, the scores injured, and hundreds arrested.

Account Name:HRMT 1 for Marikana Support Campaign
Bank: Nedbank
Branch: Constantia
Branch Code: 101109
Account No: 1011102366
Reference: Marikana Support Campaign
SWIFT: NEDSZAJJ
NB: HRMT stands for Human Rights Media Trust
The Marikana Support Campaign is supported by many organisations including:Amnesty International SA, Centre for Applied Legal Studies, Advocates For Transformation Centre for Study of Violence and Reconciliation, Equal Education Law Centre, Human Rights Media Trust, Lawyers for Human Rights, Legal Resources Centre, RAITH Foundation, Right To Know, Section 27, Social Justice Coalition, Socio-Economic Rights Institute, Treatment Action Campaign, Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union, National Council of Trade Unions, Marikana Development Forum, Wonderkop Women’s Group, Wonderkop Tribal Council, Alternative Information Development Centre, Soweto Concerned Citizens.




[2] (http://dailymaverick.co.za/article/2012-08-30-the-murder-fields-of-marikana-the-cold-murder-fields-of-marikana)

[4] Marikana: A View from the Mountain and a Case to Answer. Peter Alexander et al. London. Bookmarks Publications. 2013. p19.
[5] ‘Media bridles at attempt to curb conference coverage,’ David Smith. The Guardian. Dec 12 2012 (p33)
[6] Lonmin is the renamed British company Lonrho. The name change hides a shameful history even for an industry as brutal as mining. The firm was originally set up in 1909 to grab mining rights in what was then called Rhodesia. Even British Tory prime minister Edward Heath called Lonrho’s boss Tiny Rowland “the unacceptable face of capitalism” in 1973. This was amid allegations of tax avoidance, bribing African leaders and breaking UN sanctions against the racist regime in Rhodesia. (Socialist Worker UK, Issue 2317)

[7]  Socialist Worker UK, Issue 2317
[9] (South Africa between Reform and Revolution, Bookmarks, London 1988, p15
[11] (S Friedman, Building Tomorrow Today (Johannesburg, 1987).
[13] (African Struggles Today. Peter Dwyer and Leo Zelig. London 2012)
[14] (J Baskin, Striking Back, a history of COSATU (Verso, 1991).
[15] Communication from James Nicholl, barrister on legal team supporting miners and their families at the Farlam Commission of Inquiry.
[16] Blade Nzimande, ‘Defend the gains of the working class. Take responsibility for the national democraticd revolution’, speech distributed at the 11th COSATU Congress.
[17] Peter Alexander. Op. cit. p140
[18] Peter Alexander. Op. cit. p148
[19] Peter Alexander. Op. cit. p150
[20] David Smith. Special Report ANC leadership. The Guardian. Dec 12 2012 (p32)
[21] Peter Alexander, ‘Barricades, ballots and experimentation: making sense of the 2011 local government election with a social movement lens’. In Marcelle C. Dawson and Luke Sinwll, Contesting Transformation: Popular Resistance in Twenty-first Century South Africa (Pluto Press, London 2012).
[22] Peter Alexander. Op. cit. p146

Real Democracy Now!



Real Democracy Now!

 
 Written for website of Irish SWP www.swp.ie.

The call for ‘Real Democracy Now’ was the key demand, and ‘They don’t represent us!’ the most popular slogan, of the great Indignados movement which occupied the squares of Spain’s cities in the summer of 2011 and transformed Spanish cities. And expressed in various forms the question of democracy and the quest for ‘real’ democracy has been central to many of the mass movements of the last few years, most notably the Occupy movement in the US and elsewhere.

It was also a major factor in the mass popular protests in Bulgaria that last week brought down the right wing government of Boiko Borisov in response to a huge increase in electricity prices. The call for direct democracy, along with attacks on corruption in government, also feature heavily in the programme of the new ‘5-Star Movement’, led by comedian Beppe Grillo, which has just polled 25% of the vote in the Italian elections.

Meanwhile, here in Ireland, November 2012 saw the launch of a new party, Direct Democracy Ireland (DDI).  Their website defines direct democracy as:

       …a form of democracy in which the people have the right to:
  1. Select their own candidates to represent them.
  2. Call a referendum on any topic if a sufficient number of people deem it necessary, by gathering a set number of signatures.
  3. Create legislation and put it to a referendum if a sufficient number of people agree with it, by gathering a set number of signatures.
  4. Recall, remove from office, any representative deemed to have acted in breach of their terms of employment.
Though by no means original or specific to DDI (which in itself is not important) these sort of ideas are very likely in the current climate to strike a chord with many and may even attract significant active support. Five years of bank bail-outs and austerity, coming on the back of decades of corruption stretching back to Haughey and beyond, have generated widespread bitterness, anger and cynicism in relation to the political establishment and established politics. Whatever the relative standing of Fianna Fail and Fine Gael, the fact remains that the two parties that have completely dominated Irish political life since the foundation of the state stand, combined, at less than 50% in the polls. The massive betrayal of working class people by Labour and their partners in crime, the union leaders, has further deepened the cynicism, while the absence, up to now, of strong resistance from the organized working class means that many people are on the look out for ‘something new’. The idea of recalling corrupt or treacherous TDs seems likely to be particularly popular.
How should socialists respond to this development?
The first thing to say is that we should welcome it. We are in favour of direct democracy and a critique of how so-called ‘representative democracy’, or the parliamentary system, works has been central to the socialist and Marxist tradition ever since the Paris Commune of 1871. This extraordinary, but little known, event (because largely written out of the history books) involved the people of Paris rising up and taking over the running of their city for two and a half months until they were bloodily suppressed by a combination of the French and German armies. It was a pioneering example of direct democracy. Writing at the time Marx commented:
The Commune was formed of the municipal councillors, chosen by universal suffrage in the various wards of the town, responsible and revocable at short terms [my emphasis]…From the members of the Commune downwards, the public service had to be done at workman’s wages …The vested interests and the representation allowances of the high dignitaries of state disappeared along with the high dignitaries themselves.
…the Commune was anxious to break the spiritual force of repression, the “parson-power", by the disestablishment and disendowment of all churches as proprietary bodies. The priests were sent back to the recesses of private life, there to feed upon the alms of the faithful in imitation of their predecessors, the apostles.
The whole of the educational institutions were opened to the people gratuitously, and at the same time cleared of all interference of church and state
How much we in Ireland today can learn from the Paris Commune 142 years ago!
The socialist critique of parliamentary democracy as it exists in Ireland, Europe, North America and elsewhere stresses the following points.

1)      Elected representatives are not accountable to or recallable by their electors except once every five years, ie when the damage is done. This makes possible and even encourages promise breaking and corruption. Eamonn Gilmore can say ‘It’s Frankfurt’s Way or Labour’s Way’ and then go Frankfurt’s way all the way and promise not to serve in a government that cuts child benefit and then do just that,  and Ruari Quinn can publicly sign a pledge to oppose student fees and then raise them. ‘Isn’t that what you do at elections?’ as Pat Rabbitte put it.
2)      The lack of accountability is closely linked to the fact that we vote (once every four or five years) as isolated or ‘atomised’ individuals, not as part of any collective or on the basis of any collective debate. As a result the electors feel powerless and are highly vulnerable to the influence of the media, ie the super rich who control the media, and in between elections they do not come together to assert control over their representatives. Socialists therefore favour voting at meetings or assemblies where debate and discussion is possible.
3)      Parliaments (and local councils) are only one part of the machinery of state. In the other parts of the state apparatus – the state bureaucracy, the judiciary, the police and armed forces – there is no election or democracy at all.
4)      Most importantly, parliament is not where real power in society lies at all. Real power lies with the banks and corporations who control the wealth, finances and production of society. And just like the army and the police, the people who run these institutions are not subject to any sort of democratic election or recallability. James Connolly famously said that you could ‘remove the English army tomorrow and hoist the green flag over Dublin Castle’ but ‘England would still rule you. She would rule you through her capitalists, through her landlords, through her financiers, through the whole array of commercial and individualist institutions she has planted in this country’. With equal truth we say that we could elect any number of ‘honest’ TDs and hoist the green or even the red flag over the Dail and the capitalists will still rule us through their control of wealth and production.

Proposals to look at ways of making elected representatives accountable and to enable the people to force referenda on issues they feel strongly about are steps in the right direction and should be supported. But by themselves they don’t go far enough because they don’t tackle the undemocratic nature of economic power, of big business, the banks and the corporations. We need to make not only TDs and councilors recallable and subject to referenda if the people want it, but also the CEOs and major decisions of big business and that can’t be done without social ownership ie socialism and without mobilizing the working class

How far the members of DDI will be prepared to go in this direction remains to be seen but the fact that their ‘founder’, Raymond Whitehead, is a former night club and restaurant owner, antique dealer, and teacher of “Transcendental Meditation and The Science of Creative Intelligence” and that their ‘leader’ is Ben Gilroy of the constitution obsessed Freemen, suggests their may be problems there. Nevertheless a challenge to the extremely limited and essentially false nature of liberal parliamentary democracy which masks the rule of capital is to be encouraged.

However, it is mass mobilization from below, a crucial part of which is action from  organized workers, that will be necessary to win these or any other democratic reforms and ultimately real democracy, genuine ‘people power’ is incompatible with capitalism which, by its very nature, involves the rule of the many by the few.

John Molyneux












Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Preface to 'Marxism and the Party', (Korean edition, 2013)




Preface to Marxism and the Party (Korea 2013)

It is an honour for any author to have a book reprinted thirty five years after it was first published, so I am very grateful to Chaekgalpi and it is always a privilege to be able to contribute, in even a small way, to the struggle in Korea.

Marxism and the Party, my first book, was written out of a particular historical experience – working to build a revolutionary party in Britain during the major upsurge in working class struggle in the years 1968-74  – a period excellently analysed in Chris Harman The Fire Last Time: 1968 and After.

Since then a huge amount of historical water has flowed under the bridge, too much for me to offer any detailed account of it here. However, in the broadest possible terms, it can be said that if 1968-74 was an international upturn in the struggle, the period that followed, certainly the 80s (the years of Reagan and Thatcher) and much of the 90s, saw a deep international down. The major exception to this, the mobilizations that brought about the fall of ‘Communism’ in Eastern Europe and Russia in 1989-91 and which were an important democratic advance, were nevertheless not perceived as a step forward by most the public and most of the left, who thought that, in some sense or other, they were witnessing the downfall of socialism not the downfall of state capitalism. Only with the famous Seattle Demonstration in 1999 and the birth of the global ‘anti-capitalist’ movement, developing into the global anti-war movement, did the international tide begin to turn, and we are now a decade on from that with many further important developments.

So, two obvious questions arise: 1) to what extent do I still stand by what I wrote more than thirty five years ago? 2) how relevant is the book and its main arguments to contemporary circumstances?.

The answer to the first question is almost entirely. Clearly one hopes to learn over the years and therefore if I were rewriting this book today I would aim to improve it but I still hold to the same essential politics and I believe I rendered the ideas of the great Marxists on the nature and role of the revolutionary party pretty accurately. The only important exceptions to this are the sections on Gramsci and Trotsky. As I wrote in the preface to the 2003 Korean edition:

The chapter on Gramsci was written before I was aware of the massive appropriation of his ideas by Eurocommunism and its intellectual fellow travellers for the purposes of reformism and class collaboration. Gramsci’s formulations in the Prison Notebooks contain a number of ambiguities on which I tended to give him the benefit of the doubt, but which were exploited by his epigones to seriously distort his legacy. Writing today I would take account of this and, while defending Gramsci as a genuine revolutionary, would offer a more critical treatment.

Regarding Trotsky I can quote from my introduction to the 1986 English edition.
In addition I would also devote more space to the conception of party and class embodied in Trotsky’s strategic writings of 1928-37, in other words his critique of the Stalinist ‘third period’ ultra-leftism which divided the working class in the face of Hitler and of the subsequent opportunism of the Popular Front period.

The reason I made that comment then is that those writings had proved extremely useful in the (successful) fight we in Britain waged against the rise of the Nazi National Front in the second half of the 1970s. The reason I repeat it here is that fight against fascism, especially in Greece, but also across Europe and beyond remains of crucial importance today.

On the question of relevance it is necessary to say something about the general political situation today.

The first point, of course, is that we are living through the most severe and extended economic crisis of capitalism since the Great Depression of the 1930s. This has been extensively analysed by Marxists of all persuasions and, particularly, by Marxists in the international socialist tradition (Chris Harman, Alex Callinicos, Joseph Choonara etc) so it is only necessary to reiterate the most essential things here. These are that we are dealing with a fundamental crisis of the system, not just a banking or financial crisis, rooted in the tendency of the rate of profit to decline, that even after four years the crisis is continuing, with no real end in sight, and that this makes the question of who will pay for this crisis, their class or ours, the central issue of this period internationally.

The second point is the rising tide of resistance. Since, roughly, the end of 2010 we have seen a massive wave of revolt across the world. The Tunisian and Egyptian Revolutions of early 2011, the initial uprisings in Libya and Bahrain, the Syrian Revolution the Indignados movement in Spain, the extended resistance of the Greek working class, the Occupy movement in the USA and elsewhere, mass student movements in Canada and Chile, the widespread struggles of workers in China and India, and various revolts and strikes in Africa (especially the Marikana miners) are all different moments of this immense development. Taken as a whole it is the largest wave of rebellion since the late sixties/early seventies. Because our rulers will fight back with all the multitude of means at their disposal, it is unavoidable that this general movement, as well scoring striking victories – such as the removal of Mubarak in Egypt - will also suffer setbacks and defeats, as in Libya and Bahrain. Nevertheless, the overall trajectory continues and this is creating a new and wider audience for Marxist ideas as evidenced by – among other things - the huge increase in the publication of Marxist literature.

Third, there is climate change. There is no avoiding the fact that the issue of climate change has been at the back rather than front of the consciousness of most of the left over the last few years and that, so far, it has not – in most countries – generated a serious scale of mobilization. I hope I am wrong about this but I would expect this state of affairs to continue for a period, partly because the issue remains an abstract, not a concrete one, for most working people, and partly because it is not possible to make credible demands to most national governments to fix the problem.
However it is also a fact that climate change is proceeding at an even faster rate than most scientists predicted and that 2012 and early 2013 saw a proliferation of the extreme weather events that climate change produces. The United States, which experienced its hottest summer on record with drought in about 40 states and extensive forest fires combined with the devastation of Superstorm Sandy in the New York area and freak tornados in the south, was an example of this. As I write Australia is locked in an intense, and again record breaking heatwave, while the arctic ice is melting at such a rate that at an artic free of ice in the summer is less than a decade away. This in turn brings the world closer to the tipping point at which massive ongoing climate change becomes close to unstoppable.

Moreover climate change interacts with the economic crisis. Capitalism in crisis, obsessed with restoring profit rates and economic growth, is proving completely incapable of addressing this problem.  But, of course, it will be capable of responding to increasing natural disasters and the victims and refugees they inevitably produce with callousness, racism, war and fascist barbarity.

The combination of these facts makes the international socialist revolution and the building of revolutionary parties to secure its victory more important than ever. But here we face something of a paradox, namely that despite the intense crisis the general mood on the left is in many ways hostile to the party building project.

Recalling the period in which Marxism and the Party was first written, emphasises this. Although at that time, anarchism and spontanism had some influence, the main debate on the far left was between various political tendencies who claimed at least verbal allegiance to Leninism: traditional Communism (ie Stalinism), Maoism, Castroism, varieties of Trotskyism and so on. Behind Marxism and the Party, therefore, stood the aim of vindicating the International Socialist tradition’s interpretation of Leninism in opposition, particularly, to Stalinist and so-called ‘orthodox’ Trotskyist interpretations. This meant emphasing, above all, the dynamic and interactive (dialectical) relationship between the party and the real, living working class.

Today the picture is very different. Today there is almost an ‘anti-party’ consensus, especially among newly radicalising youth. In Spain the starting point of the great Indignados movement, with its mass occupation of city squares and its demand for ‘real democracy now’, was opposition to all political parties and trade unions. Revolutionary militants in Madrid and Barcelona were allowed into the squares only as individuals, not as members of organisations with banners and papers. Similar tendencies existed in Occupy in the US, London , Ireland and elsewhere, and even – if to a lesser extent- Tahrir Square and the streets of Cairo.

I would not label this ‘anti-party’ consensus anarchist or autonomist, though anarchists and autonomists can certainly make use of it, because I think its roots lie not in the influence of Bakunin or Kropotkin or Hardt and Negri, but in a radicalised version of neo-liberal individualism which developed a very strong hold on youth consciousness over the past couple of decades. But whatever its origins this mood is a widespread fact. Does this mean, as is often claimed, that the idea of a revolutionary party has had its day? Not in my opinion, but it does mean that the argument may need to begin ‘further back’, as it were, than it does in this book with a defence of the need for political parties as such. As I have written recently:

As for the idea that there is something wrong with political parties as such we have, of course, to recognize how understandable such a reaction is in the face of the manifest behaviour of virtually all the parties most people have experience of, and we also need to understand there really is something wrong with the existence of political parties in that they are symptoms and expressions of a class divided society and thus exhibit many of the horrible characteristics of class society[1]. However given the actual existence of class society and the fact that the working class cannot walk away from this society and establish utopia elsewhere but has to fight for its liberation from within, and on the ground of, this society it has to be said that the existence of political parties is a gain and a necessary condition of even limited democracy.
First it should be noted that, historically, political parties developed hand in hand with the development of (bourgeois) democracy and the extension of the franchise to working people in the nineteenth century. Prior to that there existed not parties but only loose associations among ‘notables’ ie aristocrats and leading bourgeois. It was only the winning of the right to vote by the masses that obliged the upper and middle classes and the workers themselves to form parties to fight for those votes. Second, the only modern societies where multiple parties do not exist are those where they are forcibly suppressed by military, fascist or Stalinist dictatorships, ie where there is no democracy at all.
Moreover, imagine it were possible (of course, it is not), in a capitalist society, to secure without repression the voluntary dissolution of all political parties so that all deputies, MPs, councillors etc were unaffiliated individuals. Would this benefit the working class and the majority of people?  No, it would not. On the contrary in such circumstances it would the rich, the bourgeoisie, who would benefit enormously because they would be able to use their personal wealth and all their other advantages (connections, cultural capital etc) to dominate politics even more than they do at present. Only through collective organization – be it in unions or in parties – are working people able to resist the power of capital and the domination of the bourgeois. (John Molyneux, ‘In Defence of Leninism’, Irish Marxist Review 3, p.43 www.irishmaristreview.net )
However, even among left-wing socialists who accept the need for a party of some sort there is a widely expressed preference for a ‘broad’ left party, rather than a specifically revolutionary or Leninist organization. The main example of this is the international surge of more or less uncritical enthusiasm for Syriza in Greece, from the moment it became clear that it had a chance of winning a parliamentary majority. Other examples include the relative success of the Front de Gauche in France (compared to the avowedly revolutionary NPA), the Left Bloc in Portugal, Die Linke in Germany, the high poll results for the Red-Green Alliance in Denmark and the yearning often expressed for such a party in Britain (unformed because the people who could form it refuse to break with the Labour Party).
Of course the emergence and progress of such broad parties of the radical left is welcome in that it is a symptom and expression of the working class moving to the left, but those who counterpose such parties to the building of revolutionary parties and hail them as the main way forward are ignoring the tragic history of left reformist governments, most notably Salvador Allende’s Popular Unity in Chile in 1970-73, which ended in Pinochet’s brutal military coup, and the Popular Front government of Spain in 1936 which succumbed to Franco and fascism, as well as the historical experience of left reformism as a whole (Menshevism in Russia, Kautskyism in Germany, the Socialist Party in Italy in 1918-21 and many other examples.
The fundamental weakness of left reformism, as Lenin emphasized in The State and Revolution, is its fudging of the need to smash the capitalist state as opposed to taking it over. As a consequence left reformist governments are either captured by the capitalist state or destroyed by it.
The necessity of an independent organization of revolutionaries – the hallmark of Bolshevism and much discussed in this book – to secure the victory of the revolution was hard won. Great revolutionaries such as Luxemburg and Trotsky fully grasped it only on the basis of the experience of both the First World War and the Russian Revolution. In the case of Luxemburg it is arguable that she paid with her life for not realizing it earlier; for Trotsky it was the main lesson of the success in October 1917 and the failure of the revolution in Germany in 1923. He wrote in The Lessons of October in 1924.:
Without a party, apart from a party, over the head of a party, or with a substitute for a party, the proletarian revolution cannot conquer. That is the principal lesson of the past decade…We have paid far too dearly for this conclusion -- with regard to the role and importance of a party in a proletarian revolution -- to renounce it so lightly or even to minimize its significance. http://www.marxist.com/classics-old/trotsky/lessonsoct.html#7

Clearly I subscribed to this view when I wrote this book. The question is have any of the numerous changes and developments of the intervening years served to invalidate this conclusion today. In my view absolutely not and, regardless of the prevailing ‘mood’ or sentiment, I believe that it will be confirmed in the struggles that lie ahead.  Therefore, given the immense crisis facing humanity, it is essential that the difficult task of building mass revolutionary workers parties be persisted with.
John Molyneux
22 January, 2013


[1] See the discussion of some of these problems in John Molyneux, ‘On Party Democracy,’ International Socialism 124, (2009).